| In the Book |
In the Movie |
|
Jacob tells Charlie that he kissed Bella in the living room. Charlie replies happily saying "Good for you". |
He says he kissed Bella in front of the house, just as Edward and Jacob are about to fight. Jacob's response is: "I kissed Bella, and she broke her hand, punching my face. Total misunderstanding." Charlie looks shocked. |
|
When Edward finds out that Jacob forcibly kissed on Bella, Edward threatens him in a low, calm voice. |
Edward threatens him by yelling and shouting at him in an uncontrolled voice.
|
|
Bella expresses her extreme sorrow and guilt for having to reject Jacob. She later cries about her decision, with Edward comforting her. |
She tells Jacob her choice, and does not cry. |
|
Edward is calm and only slightly glances at Jacob when Bella breaks her hand punching Jacob after kissing her. |
He is furious and threatens Jacob, and Charlie comes to calm them down.
|
|
Bella wants Edward to hurt Jacob for kissing her and making her break her hand. |
Bella doesn't want either of them to fight over the kiss or her breaking her hand. |